Eggplant parm in Pittsburgh, PA: our top picks
Pittsburgh calls Bloomfield its Little Italy, and the name is earned. Beginning around 1900, Italians from a handful of towns in the Abruzzi region settled there, and Immaculate Conception parish followed in 1905. Since 2002 the Liberty Avenue business district has hosted Little Italy Days, a street festival grown big enough that not every neighbor is a fan. The city’s Italian pantry, though, sits in the Strip District: Pennsylvania Macaroni Co. has been in business since 1902, started as a pasta maker in Sharpsburg, moved to Penn Avenue after its factory burned around 1910, and is still run by the Sunseri family.
The Strip is also home to DiAnoia’s Eatery, which Dave Anoia, formerly chef de cuisine at Spoon in East Liberty, and Aimee DiAndrea opened on Penn Avenue in November 2016. By day it works as a deli, with eggplant parm among the sandwiches; at night the menu turns to pasta and larger plates. A few minutes away on Fifth Avenue, Vallozzi’s Pittsburgh carries a Greensburg family name downtown: Julian Vallozzi’s grandmother sold homemade pasta, his father built the family’s Greensburg restaurant, and Julian opened the city location in 2012, with chicken parm on a menu that also leans on Sicilian pizza and pappardelle bolognese.
The rest of the list is scattered over the hills. Cucina Vitale spent years as a small room on East Carson Street on the South Side before moving to a much larger space on Andersen Drive in Green Tree in late 2024, so older directions will steer you wrong. Out east, Pasqualino’s in Penn Hills opened in 1971 as Pizza Palace, a name some regulars still use, and has been on Frankstown Road since 1986. In the South Hills, Carbonara’s on Mt. Lebanon Boulevard puts chicken and veal parmigiano right up front on its own menu.
- DiAnoia's Eatery (Pittsburgh) — Parm Score 79. Eggplant parm comes up in 1 of the recent Google reviews we sampled. It is on the menu, too. 4.6 on Google across 2,465 reviews.
- Cucina Vitale (Pittsburgh) — Parm Score 69. Eggplant parm is on the restaurant’s own menu (checked November 2026). 4.6 on Google across 520 reviews.
- Piacquadio's Italian Restaurant & Lounge (Castle Shannon) — Parm Score 68. Eggplant parm comes up in 1 of the recent Google reviews we sampled, and the tone is positive. 4.3 on Google across 300 reviews.
We ranked 5 restaurants within 10 miles of Pittsburgh, PA. 5 of them have the parm confirmed, by reviewers or on their own menu, and Parm Scores run from 57 to 79. Only places where reviews or the menu confirm the eggplant parm are listed. How Parm Score works.
More rankings: Chicken parm in Pittsburgh, PA · Veal parm in Pittsburgh, PA · Philadelphia, PA · Scranton, PA · Best eggplant parm in Pennsylvania
5 restaurants ranked for Eggplant parm near Pittsburgh, PA.
- DiAnoia's Eatery
2549 Penn Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15222, USA - Cucina Vitale
661 Andersen Dr #100, Pittsburgh, PA 15220, USA - Piacquadio's Italian Restaurant & Lounge
Lebanon Shops, 300 Mt Lebanon Blvd, Castle Shannon, PA 15234, USA - Garbarino's
5925 Baum Blvd, Pittsburgh, PA 15206, USA - Pino's
6738 Reynolds St, Pittsburgh, PA 15206, USA
Rankings use Parm Score (Google rating, review volume, and parm mentions). Restaurants with the parm confirmed, by reviews or on their own menu, always rank first. Photos, ratings, and hours from Google Maps. Interactive map and filters load above. How Parm Score works.